Site icon The Orkney News

“The allegations that have been raised by Dr Habib are deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness.”

The Scottish Government has ordered an independent review into NHS Grampian’s response to concerns raised by Dr Mohammed Habib and others over the delivery of hepatobiliary (HPB) surgery.

On 17 November, the Scottish Government’s Health Secretary, Angela Constance appointed an external Intervention Support Team to work alongside NHS Grampian providing expertise in organisational recovery, clinical governance, patient safety and performance improvement.

A diagnostic review was requested by Laura Skaife-Knight, Chief Executive, NHS Grampian. She said:

“I fully understand and acknowledge the concern in the community and amongst our staff following the publication of the HIS report last week. I apologise for our failings and for letting patients and staff down.

“The NHS Grampian Board takes the report very seriously. We own and accept the findings.

“We are determined to put things right and ensure this pivotal moment is a catalyst for much-needed change at NHS Grampian with an unrelenting focus on improving patient safety, experience and outcomes.”

The report found 4 key issues at NHS Grampian

  1. Dr Gray’s Hospital is insufficiently integrated within NHS Grampian
  2. NHS Grampian has repeatedly failed to resolve clinical governance concerns effectively
  3. NHS Grampian’s Board level scrutiny and oversight of clinical governance are inadequate
  4. NHS Grampian’s leadership and management of the medical workforce are weak.

The report found –

widespread evidence of passivity, limited constructive challenge and a
reluctance to question established ways of working, even where concerns were well recognised. In some areas, this was accompanied by a lack of openness and a sense of fatalism about long-standing problems. Insufficiently effective executive leadership and oversight have allowed some unacceptable arrangements to become normalised, with concerns persisting despite repeated attempts to address them.

At its most concerning, this culture can weaken accountability, inhibit organisational learning and reduce the likelihood that weak assurance, emerging risks and persistent problems will be robustly challenged and resolved.

The First Minister of Scotland, John Swinney, has instructed officials to preserve potentially relevant records. Angela Constance, the Health Secretary, is expected to give a statement to the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday 24 November setting out more details on who will lead the review, its scope and timetable.

Angela Constance said:

“The allegations that have been raised by Dr Habib are deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness. Patient safety and high-quality care must always be the first concern of all those who work in, and with, the NHS.”

“My thoughts are with anyone who has lost a loved one and I am acutely aware of the courage it has taken Dr Habib to come forward. I recognise he has sought to do this repeatedly, over a number of years, to both to the Scottish Government and several other bodies.

“Patients and staff in Grampian have the right to expect full transparency and independent assurance that when valid concerns are raised, they are properly and robustly pursued. That is what this review will seek to establish. If any patients have questions, require advice or support they should contact the helpline established by NHS Grampian on 08085 202030.”

NHS Orkney issued the following statement:

We recognise that the Healthcare Improvement Scotland inspection reports and diagnostic review into NHS Grampian, published last week, make difficult reading and may understandably cause concern for people in Orkney who receive, or have family members receiving, care from NHS Grampian.

NHS Grampian has confirmed that work is already underway in response to the findings, including strengthening clinical governance, leadership accountability and oversight, and the reporting of and learning from adverse events.

Anyone with specific concerns or questions about their care can contact NHS Grampian’s dedicated phone line on 08085 202030, Monday to Friday, from 8am – 6pm.

While these findings relate specifically to NHS Grampian, they provide an important opportunity for all health boards to reflect on the learning and consider where further improvements can be made.

For NHS Orkney, our priority is to ensure that people from Orkney who access services through NHS Grampian continue to receive safe and compassionate care. We will continue to work closely with NHS Grampian as it responds to the findings.

Click on the links for more information on the findings of the Diagnostic Review

NHS Grampian responsive diagnostic review: November 2026 PDF, 929KB

NHS Grampian responsive diagnostic review easy read summary: November 2026 2MB

Aberdeen Maternity Hospital, NHS Grampian – maternity safe delivery of care inspection report

Dr Gray’s Hospital, NHS Grampian – maternity safe delivery of care inspection report

Dr Gray’s Hospital, NHS Grampian – acute safe delivery of care inspection report


Exit mobile version