“It Just has To Be True Until Tomorrow”

“Part of him was beginning to understand that his readers might have a very relaxed attitude about the guilt of politicians but were red hot on things like the size of the weather”

These were the musings of William de Worde as he set out reporting for The Times in Terry Pratchett’s ‘The Truth’. Fiction is very good at throwing a light on the direction of our society or as Pratchett would put it:

Sometimes a fantasy author has to point out the strangeness of reality.”

I was raised in a home where the BBC was seen as the number one (literally) tv station of choice and very rarely did the channel change, certainly not for the news. The BBC news was seen as reliable, not always unbiased but pretty much the fairest you could get. Certainly as far as its reporters, journalists and news readers were concerned as ‘to be believed‘. Over the years that faith in the state broadcaster has been eroded and this process has accelerated from the Scottish referendum in 2014, General Election 2015, Scottish Election 2016, EU Referendum 2016, local elections 2017 and now it has reached fever pitch with the General Election 2017.

Helping them out with their answers, pushing their propaganda for them by not questioning them on either their policies or their past record is slowly eating away at our democratic process. People who once went to the BBC for their news no longer do so. Young people especially tend to get their news online from a variety of sources. Holding politicians to account is a crucial role for journalists. It is also the responsiblity of the electorate.

But this is not about the complicit role BBC News and the Main Stream Media has had in pushing a one vision fits all austerity agenda for the UK. This column is about our role in the electoral process: We The People.

I have been reading Al Franken’s book ‘Lies And The Lying Liars Who Tell Them‘: it is solely about American politics and because of that I struggled with some of the references but the tactics used in  US Presidential Elections have crossed the Atlantic.

Al says:

“this book brings to a new level the politics of personal destruction that have come to define our era.”

It does just that – it documents and cross references meticulously how smears, misinformation, and down right blatant lies have been used very successfully with a Murdoch dominated media machine to massage public opinion.  Push polling, which has made an appearance in the UK is ‘a sneaky way to spread lies about your opponent whilst appearing to keep your own hands clean.’ Push polling is where an elector is posed a question by an independent polling agent who says they are wishing to gather information. But they are neither gathering information nor are they independent. What they will do will be to frame a question in such a way as to perpetuate a smear against a particular politician.

Then are any polls reliable anymore? What is their purpose? Is it to sway public opinion as in ‘there’s no point voting for them because they will not win’? Is a poll of 1000 people who have landlines and are indoors during the short summer months in the UK any reliable account of current public opinion? And despite their astonishing failures to predict results over the last few years they have remained as a source of ‘facts’ and  their ‘facts’ spread over TV, radio, Newspapers and online often being treated with a reverence that they no longer deserve (if they ever did).

Entering into political language over the last few years is the macho verbiage of conflict. All the political parties apparently are claiming to be  ‘stronger’ for us. And while they do so it is our democracy which is weakening. Claiming the 2014 Scottish referendum where more people than ever in Scotland became engaged in politics and openly discussed the issues around a self governing small nation as divisive is a disgraceful statement for any politician to make. No one got killed during that Referendum. Just a lot of discussions some of them more heated than others – but discussions about the future direction of your country.

Contrast that with the EU Ref where the language of hate was stoked up by little generals keen on ‘making history’ – well they did just that with the murder of the MP Jo Cox as she went about her normal business of dealing with local community issues.

Violence has entered our electoral process with the tragedies of Manchester and London taking innocent lives from their families, from us. UK Government arms deals with Saudi Arabia, facilitating drone attacks in Libya and Syria, the appalling instablity in Afghanistan where a few days ago 90 people were killed when a massive car bomb went off – our hands are not just dirty, they are blood red filthy.  And the response by the UK Government is to prevent those fleeing violence in their own countries to find sanctuary in ours and to seek ways to censor the internet. The public’s only way to find sources of information other than from the state.

At a more local level I would ask you to read the leaflets that come through your door and do so with a critical eye. Out of the 5 political parties standing in Orkney and Shetland  4 of them are standing against independence and it fills their leaflets. The SNP leaflet, rather disingenuously considering what the main aim of that party is, does not mention it at all. How bizarre.  The 4 parties: Liberal Democrats, Labour, Conservatives and UKIP  who do go on about stopping  an independence referendum seem to be ignoring the vote in the Scottish Parliament which voted in favour of such a referendum taking place. Maybe they do not accept the legitimacy of the Scottish Parliament only elected a year ago and by proportional representation. And then there’s the SNP leaflet with no mention at all of independence, their founding aim.

All the leaflets claim things they cannot do. This is a General Election so all those claiming to improve Scottish Education, the Health Service or getting rid of the council tax – all that is rubbish as those are devolved matters and who we vote for in Orkney and Shetland will have no competency over those issues.

What is missing? Any real discussion of Brexit which this snap General Election was supposed to be all about and which will have a massive effect on  Orkney and Shetland. The Liberal Democrats don’t even discuss Brexit they just want another referendum on exiting the EU – a referendum that was truly divisive stirring up hatred towards those who have chosen to make the UK their home. And after their sell out to the Tories in the coalition Government of Cameron and Clegg what can we believe if anything of the promises they are making.

I haven’t mentioned the dodgy graphs on both the Conservative and Liberal Democrat leaflets. They are simply ridiculous.

The decision is yours and yours alone. We do get the politicians we deserve if we don’t engage, if we don’t question, and if we don’t look with a critical eye at the promises they make and the language and tactics they use. Your vote is the most powerful weapon available. It was  hard won. Don’t disregard its strength.

As Al Franken says:

“We have to be more vigilant. We have to fight back. We have to expose those who bear false witness for the fake witness bearers that they are. And we have to do it in a straight forward, plainspoken way. Let’s call them what they are: liars, Lying, lying liars.”

Or as Terry Pratchett would say:

” the truth has got its boots on…It’s going to start kicking.”

Opinion Piece by  Fiona Grahame (The views are entirely my own.)


Lies And The Lying Liars Who Tell Them by Al Franken


 The Truth by Terry Pratchett

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as: , , , ,

7 replies »

  1. Great piece Fiona. You have put in to words something I have been trying to tell about not listening to MSM and try and tap in to on line media for a fairer spin on the facts.
    It is a disgrace how the state broadcaster is getting away with what they are doing with another prime example in last nights QT where out First Minister was confronted by a crowd of unionist and a presenter who could not be more blue Tory if he tries!

  2. Phew – I don’t know where to begin – this covers much of what I’ve been puttering and puttering about – so – just some bits & pieces……….

    1) Years ago, friend Philip worked for Visnews – a news distribution company – as a news editor, and he told me then, that what the public got to see, was what the public were given to see.

    2) To quote Paul Weller – “The pubic wants what the public gets.”

    3)To quote Faithless – “Mis-information is a weapon of mass-destruction.”

    4) A link to Fred Turner’s piece about….the world situation – not today, or yesterday or tomorrow – but ..the world situation.
    But, yes, it does only have to be true for now, or, it has to be what folk want it to be, for now. How they want to see it – the ‘good guys’ and the ‘bad guys’.


    It’s down to us, in the countries where the public can vote – and in the countries where the people can’t vote ??
    Remember – that was true here, not all that long ago. Things change. The public, even if they don’t have the vote, can take action which may lead to them getting the vote. Then….well it is up to them, up to us. If we choose foolishly – that’s how it is. Democracy – doesn’t always work as it should, but sure as hell better than most other options!
    And as for lying – it’s what politicians do. I don’t say that make it acceptable. I accept it, as what is so, not as what is right, and work with that as best I can.
    Lord, I could witter on about this.

  3. Sadly now on several occasions and in different ways I have tried to engage and have not received a reply from the SNP candidate …… If anyone wants a reason for the all time low turnouts to vote here it is. We are floating voters …. Have had answers from the liar and other candidates and will not vote for them so mirriam was, we hoped the answer, but no reply must give us the answer …. So that’s two less voters 🙁 for the first time everi won’t vote I do not think there is a single candidate worth voting for .. . Surely we deserve decent interested and honest politicians? Or if not how about an extra box on the form where we can state that in our opinions they are all aresholes? I think that would give honest feedback on what people think of politicians

Leave a Reply