RSPB Cuts Hoy Warden Hours

By Bernie’s Blog

I saw a post on the  Orkney Wildlife Facebook page… about the position of RSPB Warden on Hoy being cut to part-time and wanted to sign the petition mentioned there, asking the RSPB to reconsider – but couldn’t work out how.

I emailed Ross Flett to ask,  and Ross helpfully replied….

”I had that problem as well and have just discovered that the actual post is the petition so it’s just a matter of adding the word ‘signed’ in comments.” 

I had a go, but I can’t access the site to post a comment – possibly because I’m not on Facebook.  I can look at the pages, but can’t interact with them.   I tried going to the original post on the Hoy Facebook site – and Facebook wouldn’t even let me look at it!

Not everyone is on Facebook, and this could mean that other folk who would like to sign – can’t. 

Where there’s a will, there’s a way, so I thought I’d approach it this way so that even if I can’t – others can – if they choose to…..and are on Facebook!

Someone who can access Facebook copied the link and the text for me…. here it is…

“Please sign the petition below calling on the RSPB to reverse their decision to cut the Hoy warden job to part time.

If you want to sign just write ‘signed’ in the comments.

Paper petitions will also be available on the island.

Can I please ask that people avoid adding any other comments on this post for now.

Thank you.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

The RSPB has taken the decision to cut the RSPB warden post in Hoy to a part time job.

The reserve makes up almost a third of our island and includes some of the most important features of our landscape, including the Old Man of Hoy, St John’s Head and the Ward Hill.

The RSPB have decided they can manage and maintain this important part of our island, and our community’s heritage, with a part time post.

The RSPB has failed to take into account the impact this will have, not only on the management of a vast part of our island, but on our small community, of which the warden and her family are integral part.

The warden’s job currently supports a family of 4 to live in Hoy. The warden has lived and worked in Hoy for 20 years, she has a wealth of knowledge and experience both of the reserve and as a member of our island community. A part time post cannot support a family to live on the island. This effectively means the warden, her husband and two young children, will have to leave their family home, as their house is owned by the RSPB and is tied to the job.

This decision has been taken with no consultation with our community and we are stunned and horrified that an organisation such as the RSPB can treat their employee, our friend and neighbour, and our community, in this manner.

We the undersigned demand the RSPB recognise the consequences of their actions and reverse the decision to cut the warden post.

And this – about a public meeting on Friday….

This decision on the part of the RSPB  is very bad indeed – they are one of the richest charities around – they can well afford to keep the post as full time. 

Also – think how many visitors are attracted to Hoy because of the birds – including in recent years – Eagles!  That’s a good thing, but more people means that more vigilance is necessary on the part of the Warden.

Maybe, somewhere in the labyrinth of offices at the RSPB HQ this makes economic sense – but money isn’t everything – and they have plenty.

I’ll also contact the RSPB about it.  Mike and I are long-standing members of the RSPB , and have increasingly come to the conclusion that – as happens with many organizations –  they have got too big and lost sight of their initial aims.

This decision is simply un-necessary and wrong.

Rackwick Bay Hoy

Categories: Uncategorized

Tagged as: , , ,

6 replies »

  1. A vast and important area like Hoy needs a lot of looking after and a full time Warden to organise all of the work we, as volunteers, need to help with, as well as fulfilling all of the other tasks/obligations the RSPB needs to deliver on Hoy.
    Working as I have with the public on the Eagles project alone is a big undertaking and there are many other work parties that need to be organised and managed to keep Hoy alive and vibrant as an important part of the RSPB’s work.
    The Hoy Warden also makes a very important contribution to the work of the RSPB in Orkney overall
    In my opinion the RSPB needs to think again and meet their obligations by retaining the vital post of a full time warden on Hoy. Otherwise they will be managing nothing more than progressive decline on Hoy and Orkney generally.

    • Thank you Ian – your reinforcement of the importance of a full time ‘guardian ‘ for the Eagles, will now go to all the places that I’m sending this article and my blog post!

      Here’s a scenario.. what if….lots of people coming hoping to see the Eagles….no-one there to guide them as to the best way to approach that aim – disturbance – eggs stolen? – Eagles go away again.

      It’s possible…..

  2. PS
    Following the post in my blog and the item in ‘The Orkney News’, I had the following exchange with Stewart Bain, RSPB Communications & Events Officer for Orkney……make of it what you will!

    “Hi Bernie,

    I have just read your piece on the current restructure of the reserves team in Orkney and I thought the statement below from Josh Wells, Senior Sites Manager in Orkney, may be helpful. As you will see, the hours dedicated to the Hoy reserve are remaining the same under the restructure.

    Kind regards,



    Ahead of the meeting with the Hoy community on Friday evening, we would like to provide some context and clarity regarding the current restructure of our warden team in Orkney. As a charity with the conservation of birds and wildlife as its central priority, RSPB Scotland must find the best way to protect and restore nature in Orkney with the resources we have available, while maintaining the responsibilities and commitments we have to our staff, nature reserves and the communities we are part of.

    To do our best for nature, it is imperative that we make some changes to the structure of the small team of wardens who look after our reserves in Orkney. Reallocating some resource to our suite of eight Mainland reserves will help us to meet our objectives most effectively and ensure priority work can be delivered and is shared more equally across the team. The responsibilities of the current warden role based in Hoy are split 60/40 between Hoy and Orkney Mainland nature reserves. However, the practicalities of this are challenging. Under the new structure, there will be no reduction in staff time dedicated to the Hoy Nature Reserve. Hoy will retain a three days per week allocation based on the island, while the other two days per week will become part of a full-time role resulting from a wider restructure. This role will have the Orkney Mainland as its base and deliver work across RSPB Scotland’s suite of Mainland reserves.

    We recognise that the Hoy warden is a valued part of the community and understand the concerns regarding these changes. The restructure has followed a full review of our reserve staffing and associated workloads, which identified areas that need increased input to maximise conservation benefits. We encourage everyone with an interest in this matter to attend the meeting at the North Walls Community Centre at 7.30pm on Friday 24 March, where you will be able to share your views with us and we will give more detail on why the changes are necessary and our continued commitment to the Hoy Nature Reserve.


    Stewart Bain
    Communications & Events Officer
    07554 331138 | 01856 852025

    And my response….

    “Hi Stewart

    I read this with interest, and wonder at the two, slightly varying interpretations of what is going to happen. My response was to the first version of events which came my way.

    Is it OK with you if I post this as a PS to my blog, and as a ‘comment’ to the piece in The Orkney News?

    All in the interest of clarity!


    Stewart said ‘yes’ – so here it is. Should be a lively meeting – to which I can’t go as health difficulties make travelling – difficult – for me these days.

Leave a Reply