On 15 May 1940, Andrew Dalton Pirie, was sent to prison for 1 month for a reckless shooting at Aithsdale, Walls.

During World War 2 there was a huge influx into Orkney of not just military personnel, given its strategic location, but of thousands of workers, vital to the war effort.

Pirie was a machinist over at the Royal Navy base at Lyness, Hoy. On Tuesday 14 May 1940 he had assaulted Maurice Frederick Perkins the catering manager of a firm at Lyness. Pirie had pointed a .45 loaded pistol at Perkins and fired it into the air. Unsurprisingly this greatly alarmed both Perkins and Audrey Rendall living at Aithsdale.

The gun and six rounds of ammunition, which Pirie had in his possession, were confiscated. For these he had the option of a £5 fine or 10 days imprisonment added to his already 1 month of incarceration.

An image of Lyness today overlaid with an image of what it was like when the base was completed including the 4 oil tanks
Image of Lyness then and now on the wall at the Scapa Flow Visitor Centre, Hoy

Walls must have been a bit wilder than the years between the two world wars because of the number of men (and women) now in the island. There are several incidences of civilian workers being hauled before the Sheriff Court for offences. On the same day that Pirie was in court, a labourer Edwin Lee Moore Harper was charged with taking and driving away a motor lorry without the consent of the owners from a camp in Walls.

Harper had no driving licence, or insurance. He was further charged with driving the lorry recklessly and at a speed and manner dangerous to the public. He pled guilty and had previous convictions in Northern Ireland in 1939.

The lorry had been left unattended with the engine running whilst the driver went into the camp to speak to a Sergeant. They rushed out when they heard the lorry being driven away. At this point the two men jumped into another lorry and gave chase. Harper lost control of his lorry on a bend, went through a hedge and landed in a ditch.

The Sheriff warned Harper that he could be sentenced to :

  1. £50 fine or 3 months imprisonment for taking the lorry without the owner’s consent
  2. £50 fine or 3 months imprisonment for having no insurance
  3. for having no driving licence – although he had been disqualified in Northern Ireland, it was in doubt whether the disqualification applied in Scotland, but there may be a £30 fine or imprisonment under the Summary Jurisdiction Act
  4. for reckless driving – a £50 fine or imprisonment under the Summary Jurisdiction Act.

Reacting to the sentencing Harper stated : ‘I did it under the influence of drink’.

To which the Sheriff said: ‘You are not charged with that.’

In his final judgment the Sheriff turned to the accused:

“You have made too much of a habit of this kind of a thing. £10 or one month on the third charge, and a month’s imprisonment on each of the others. we will also renew that Irish disqualification for 5 years.”

Harper refused to pay the fine of £10 and another month was added to his term of imprisonment. His prison sentence would total 4 months.

Quite a contrast in sentencing between Harper, 4 months for dangerous driving, and Pirie just 1 month for possessing, pointing a weapon, and firing it at two people.

Fiona Grahame


Leave a Reply

Trending