Science

Improving The Detection of Inherited Rare Conditions in Scotland

Rare conditions affect an estimated 8% of the population of Scotland and around 80% of these conditions have a genetic cause.

There are more than 150,000 gene abnormalities known to cause developmental and learning difficulties and a host of conditions that impact long term health. But many patients are undiagnosed which has a huge impact on their life and their families.

 A new study involving the University of Aberdeen has found that the detection and management of inherited rare and serious conditions in routine care can be improved by genome sequencing.

A major research programme has sequenced 1,000 genomes from Scottish residents with rare conditions and their family members and sent the data for processing and storage into the 100,000 Genomes Project– a flagship project set up in England to advance clinical care through genome research. NHS Scotland genetic scientists and doctors then interpreted the analysed data and passed useful results to participants. A genetic diagnosis has been found in 23% so far and more answers are coming from research on the data being carried out in Genomics England’s protected online research environment and from an SGP extension project, funded to look for more complex genome rearrangements.

With funding from NHS Scotland, the Scottish Government and the UK Medical Research Council, the SGP involved the Universities of Aberdeen, Edinburgh, Glasgow, and Dundee, NHS Grampian, NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde, NHS Lothian, and NHS Tayside.

The project chief investigator, Professor Zosia Miedzybrodzka of the University of Aberdeen, said:

“We have set up a system for Scottish patients to have genomes sequenced as part of their care. But we have also found that a more targeted genome wide approach- the exome- recently funded by the Scottish Government as part of routine care- can give us similar numbers of diagnoses at less cost.

“The Scottish Government is using the study results to inform policy on what will be available in NHS Scotland in coming years. If analysis of genome sequence improves as expected, and the costs fall, Scotland will be well placed to implement the technology.

“Having an undiagnosed genetic condition brings a huge amount of worry for those affected but it is our hope that diagnosis through genome sequencing can bring answers and improve the lives of patients and their families.”

The partnership between Scottish universities, NHS genetics labs and clinics and Genomics England, offered whole genome sequencing to families with rare, inherited conditions where previous genetic testing had not identified a genetic cause.  

Professor Tim Aitman, University of Edinburgh, said:

“The publication of the SGP results represents a landmark for application of genome technology to the healthcare of Scottish patients with rare genetic disorders.

“With over 1000 high quality genome sequences now generated at the Edinburgh Genomics facility; new diagnoses have been found for dozens of patients who previously remained undiagnosed after standard genetic testing.

“The SGP focus on genome technology and genome informatics has increased the available expertise in these areas and the insights gained from the SGP are now being fed into Scottish healthcare policy, giving a long-term legacy of the SGP rare diseases project for Scottish patients.

“Continuously reducing costs of genome sequencing stand to increase future availability of genome-based testing for patients with rare diseases in Scotland.”

The study of the Scottish Genomes Partnership has been published in the European Journal of Human Genetics: Genome sequencing with gene panel-based analysis for rare inherited conditions in a publicly funded healthcare system: implications for future testing

Natalie Frankish, Policy and Engagement Manager for Scotland, Genetic Alliance UK, said:

“Many people with rare conditions face significant challenges in getting a diagnosis, with more than a third of people with a rare condition having to wait more than five years. This diagnostic odyssey can have a significant impact on the quality of life and wellbeing for a person with a rare condition and their family.

“A diagnosis can lead to improved medical management and can open doors to accessing care, treatment and support services.  It is encouraging to see that recent investment in genome-based testing through the Scottish Genomes Partnership has given 88 patients new diagnoses, we hope that this news will help these families access the care and support that they need.

“Ensuring a fast and accurate diagnosis is important for people with rare conditions. We hope that the findings published by the Scottish Genomes Partnership in this paper will help make the case for further investment in genomic, diagnostic and screening services within NHS Scotland, but we must recognise that speed of diagnosis is only part of the picture. 

“How a person is supported on their journey to diagnosis is equally important and we must see investment in clinical services to ensure people with rare conditions and their families receive the support that they need throughout their diagnosis journey.”